Best Container for Homemade Ice Cream | My 7 Recommendations

When enjoying homemade ice cream, the container in which it’s stored is just as important as the ingredients used to make the delight itself. You need a container that ticks all the boxes, like the right size, durability to withstand temperature changes and material safety.

However, I understand the struggle of finding the ideal container and trust me, it’s more than just about the design or price tag. After researching various options and vital factors, I’m confident a BPA-free plastic container or polypropylene container with a tight-fitting lid will keep your homemade ice cream fresh and delicious.

To help you, I’ve listed the top 7 best containers for keeping homemade ice cream fresh. Keep reading to select the right one for your needs.

Editor’s Choice

Runner Up

Best Value

7 Best Containers for Homemade Ice Cream to Keep Your Treats Fresh and Delicious

Have you ever found yourself savoring a scoop of homemade ice cream, only to be disappointed by a freezer burn or an off-flavor? Let’s explore my list of 7 best containers to keep your frozen creations fresh and delicious.

• SUMO 1.5-quart 2 tubs ice cream containers for homemade ice cream
• BALCI 1 quart 2 pack premium ice cream containers
• StarPack 2 pcs 1-liter ice cream containers for homemade ice cream
• ZICOTO 2 reusable 1.6-quart homemade ice cream tub containers
• SveBake 2 pack 1.5 quarts homemade ice cream storage containers
• Tovolo 1.5-quart glide-a-scoop containers for homemade ice cream
• Luxail 1.5-quart ice cream containers for homemade ice cream

1. SUMO 1.5-quart 2 Tubs Ice Cream Containers for Homemade Ice Cream

In my quest for the perfect homemade ice cream containers, I’ve stumbled upon the bright purple allure of the SUMO 1.5-quart containers. Durable and insulated, these tubs are a delightful find.

The first impression is one of sturdiness that withstands the freeze and the fumble. No flimsy plastic here; these containers are the real deal, ready to stop the stings of freezer burn in their tracks.

Design is everything, and these containers’ long, slim, pint-like shape makes scooping in a breeze. With these containers in hand, I am confident that navigating through a pint of peanut butter swirl will be a pleasant experience. 

These containers are also dishwasher safe, which makes the post-dessert ritual joyful. The erasable label is a thoughtful touch. It’s the organizer’s dream, whether a date label or a flavor label; there’s no room for mix-ups.

Pros:

• Durable and insulated design for maintaining ice cream freshness
• Dishwasher safe for convenient cleaning
• Erasable label for organized storage
• The slim design facilitates easy scooping

Cons:

• Concerns about lid tightness and sealing

2. BALCI 1-Quart 2 Pack Premium Ice Cream Containers

My initial impression of the BALCI containers was marked by their bold, vibrant red hue and a reassuring weight that promised durability. The B.P.A free, high-quality plastic construction meant a product designed to last, even in the frosty conditions of a home freezer.

When storing your homemade or store-bought delights, quality matters. These containers boast a tough and reusable design, characteristics that are essential for retaining the flavor and texture of your frozen delights.

These BALCI containers are more than just pretty storage; they have been precisely engineered to address the challenges of freezing and preserving treats. The interior’s smooth finish and the exterior’s textured grip make handling and serving an absolute breeze.

Also, the flexibility of the lids combined with their silicone construction ensures they seal tightly to keep out unwanted odors and prevent freezer burn.

Pros:

• Sturdy construction with smooth interior and textured exterior
• Silicone lids provide a tight seal
• Containers don’t retain odors
• The dishwasher-safe feature makes cleaning a breeze

Cons:

• Need for tighter lids to prevent ice crystals

3. StarPack 2 Pcs 1-Liter Ice Cream Containers for Homemade Ice Cream

When looking for durable and versatile containers to store your homemade ice cream, I suggest you consider the StarPack ice cream containers. Designed to keep your frozen treats fresh and easily accessible, these reusable storage containers come in a set of two, with each container holding 1 liter of ice cream.

Made of BPA-free polypropylene and silicone, they’re stackable, easy to clean, and suitable for hot or cold foods. The leak-free silicone lids ensure a secure seal, preventing freezer burn and maintaining the quality of your ice cream.

With dimensions of 5.3” tall and 4.7” wide, these containers are freezer and microwave-safe, making them convenient for storing and serving delicious homemade treats. Customers rave about their sturdiness, easy cleaning, and ability to keep ice cream fresh and scoopable.

Pros:

• Leak-free silicone lids maintain ice cream quality
• Stackable design for easy storage
• Environmentally friendly and reusable containers
• Freezer and microwave safe for versatile use
• Food-safe materials ensure no odors

Cons:

• Limited in capacity for larger batches

4. ZICOTO 2 Reusable 1.6 Quart Homemade Ice Cream Tub Containers

With my rigorous foray into finding the ideal ice cream tub, I stumbled upon ZICOTO’s two sets of reusable 1.6-quart homemade ice cream containers. Ideal for ice cream enthusiasts, the Set of 2 Reusable Ice Cream Tub Containers offers a reliable option with its stackable design and tight-sealing lids.

These BPA-free containers are dishwasher safe and come with 12 reusable labels for convenient identification. Customers appreciate the sturdy construction and cute design of these containers.

The snug fit of the lid combats freezer odors, ensuring that my ice cream stays fresh and retains its intended flavor profile with every scoop.

The stackable design makes them space-efficient in the freezer, and the slim shape allows for easy scooping. Overall, these containers are a practical choice for storing your homemade ice cream, ensuring it stays fresh and delicious.

Pros:

• Sturdy construction and cute design
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
• Stackable design for efficient storage
• Comes with 12 reusable labels for easy identification
• Slim shape makes it easy for easy scooping

Cons:

• Not well-insulated for long-term freezing

5. SveBake 2 PACK 1.5 Quarts Homemade Ice Cream Storage Containers

If you’re looking for a reliable and convenient way to preserve your homemade ice cream, let me introduce SveBake Ice Cream Storage Containers with Lids in Light Grey. These containers come in a 2-pack, each holding 1.5 quarts of delicious homemade treats.

With a double insulation design, they help keep your ice cream fresh for longer periods. The top-quality construction ensures durability, and their perfect size makes scooping ice cream a breeze. Cleaning is easy as they’re dishwasher safe.

Customers have praised these containers for their design, functionality, and ease of use. Stackable and with excellent insulation, the SveBake Ice Cream Storage Containers with Lids are a great choice to keep your frozen desserts fresh and delicious.

Pros:

• Double insulation design for longer freshness 
• Top-quality construction for durability
• Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
• Prevent ice crystals from forming on top of ice cream
• Rubber ring prevents sliding during scooping

6. Tovolo 1.5-Quart Glide-A-Scoop Containers for Homemade Ice Cream

For anyone seeking a reliable and practical solution for storing homemade ice cream, I advise you to check out the Tovolo Glide-A-Scoop Ice Cream Tub. This 1.5-quart container is designed with double-walled BPA-free plastic to prevent freezer burn and maintain freshness.

Its non-slip base provides stability while scooping, and the airtight lid prevents spills. The compact design makes it easy to store in the freezer and conveniently stackable.

According to my findings, users appreciate this insulated tub’s vibrant design and durability. With high praise for its functionality and ease of cleaning, the Tovolo Glide-A-Scoop Ice Cream Tub is ideal for storing and serving your delicious frozen treats.

Pros:

• Prevents freezer burn with double-walled BPA-free plastic
• Non-slip base for stability and perfect scooping
• Airtight lid to maintain freshness and prevent spills
• Attractive color adds a vibrant touch to kitchen storage

Cons:

• Requires hand-washing for cleaning

7. Luxail 1.5 Quart Ice Cream containers for homemade ice cream

With a double-walled design and stackable feature, the Luxail red 1.5-quart ice cream container is a practical choice if you frequently create homemade ice cream and prioritize easy storage. 

The BPA-free plastic construction helps prevent freezer burn, while the long, I assure you this thin shape allows for effortless scooping. Its non-slip base ensures stability when stacked in the freezer. Made of durable materials like polypropylene and silicone, these containers are dishwasher-safe for easy cleaning.

According to my research, customer reviews highlight the quality and functionality of the product, although some users experienced tightness and lid issues. Despite these concerns, the containers are praised for their insulation and stackability, making them recommended for storing homemade ice cream.

Pros:

• Double-walled design prevents freezer burn
• Long, thin shape for easy scooping
• Stackable with a non-slip base
• Clever design for quick and easy scoops

Cons:

• Lid tightness issues

Comparison Table for the Best Container for Homemade Ice Cream

Feature	SUMO	BALCI	StarPack	ZICOTO	SveBake	Tovolo	Luxail
Color	Purple	Red	Red	White, Purple	Grey	Orange Crush	Red
Material	Plastic	Plastic	Silicone	BPA-free plastic	Not specified	Silicone	Polypropylene, Plastic
Capacity	1.5 Quarts	1 Quart	1 Liters	1.6 Quarts	1.5 Quarts	1.5 Quarts	1.5 Quarts
Lid Type	Regular	Regular	Silicone	Regular	Regular	Airtight	Regular
Containers	2	2	2	2	2	1	1
Dimensions	8.5 x 4.5 x 5 inches	Not specified	5.3” tall X 4.7″ Wide	10.2″L x 3.9″W x 3.9″H	11″L x 4″W x 4″H	29.2L x 10.8W x 10.2H centimetres	11″L x 4″W x 4″H

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Container for Homemade Ice Cream

When buying a container for homemade ice cream, consider the following factors I’ve listed below for the right one:

Size Considerations

Considering the quantity of homemade ice cream typically made is crucial when selecting the appropriate size container. I can tell you that smaller containers work well for single servings or small batches, while larger containers are ideal for bigger batches.

Ensuring the container has enough space to prevent overflow when churning or freezing the ice cream is important. Opting for containers with some extra room allows for expansion during the freezing process. Additionally, the container size should fit comfortably in your freezer for convenient storage.

Material Durability

Select durable containers such as BPA-free plastic or polypropylene for your homemade ice cream to ensure its longevity and quality. These materials are known for their strength and resistance to cracking or breaking, ensuring your ice cream stays fresh and delicious for longer periods.

Additionally, containers with double-walled construction can help prevent freezer burn and maintain the ice cream’s texture. Investing in containers with these qualities protects your ice cream and provides a reliable option for storing your homemade treats.

Lid Tightness

Selecting ice cream containers with lids that provide a tight seal is critical for preserving the freshness and quality of homemade ice cream. A secure lid plays a vital role in preventing freezer burn, maintaining the smooth texture of the ice cream, and safeguarding its flavor.

These lids help prevent the formation of ice crystals that can compromise the overall quality of the dessert by ensuring a snug fit. Additionally, a tight-fitting lid minimizes the risk of spills and leaks, keeping the ice cream fresh for longer.

Stackability Feature

One key factor to consider when choosing a homemade ice cream container is the stackability feature. Stackable containers offer efficient storage in the freezer or fridge, saving space and organizing your freezer.

Accessing multiple flavors or batches of ice cream becomes easier with containers that stack well. This feature is especially beneficial for those with limited storage space, as it helps maintain the quality and freshness of your homemade treats.

Cleaning Ease

Considering the ease of cleaning is crucial when selecting a container for homemade ice cream. Opt for containers that are dishwasher safe to simplify the cleaning process.

Smooth interior surfaces make it effortless to scoop out every last bit of your delicious treat without any leftover residue. Easy cleaning ensures you enjoy ice cream without lingering flavors from previous batches.

Additionally, look for containers with erasable labels to help you stay organized and keep track of different flavors or batches. A clean container maintains the freshness of your ice cream and enhances the overall enjoyment of your homemade frozen delights.

Insulation Quality

A container with high-quality insulation is key to ensuring homemade ice cream’s optimal texture and flavor. Insulation quality plays a critical role in preserving the freshness of your frozen treats.

A double-walled container is especially effective at preventing freezer burn and ice crystals, which can compromise the taste and texture of your ice cream. When selecting a container, prioritize BPA-free materials that offer sufficient thermal protection to keep your ice cream at the perfect temperature.

Proper insulation helps maintain the desired consistency of the ice cream and extends its shelf life by ensuring it stays frozen longer. Investing in a container with superior insulation can significantly enhance the overall quality of your homemade ice cream.

What makes a good homemade ice cream container?

The best container for homemade ice cream is preferably plastic. This is because plastic materials have a quicker freezing capacity than glass ones.

Moreover, a shallow container can help achieve a finer ice cream texture due to quicker freezing. Lastly, selecting a container with a lid is crucial as it prevents air exposure, thereby maintaining the ice cream’s quality.

Can I put homemade ice cream in a different container?

Certainly, any freezer-safe container can store homemade ice cream. However, using a plastic container with a lid tends to make storage easier.

Even better, if the containers can be stacked, it can significantly enhance the organization of your freezer. As a tip, consider laying a piece of plastic wrap on top of the leftover ice cream within the container to keep it fresh and tasty.

How long can I store homemade ice cream?

You can store homemade ice cream in an airtight container in the freezer for up to two weeks. Beyond this time, the ice cream might lose its smooth texture, and larger ice crystals might start forming, affecting the overall ice cream experience.

What temperature should homemade ice cream containers be stored at?

The ideal temperature for storing homemade ice cream containers is 0°F (-18°C) or even lower. The temperature of a supermarket freezer should typically not exceed 10°F (-12°C). Nevertheless, the exact temperature may vary depending on the ice cream’s composition.

Which type of storage is appropriate for homemade ice cream?

The most suitable location for storing homemade ice cream is in the central part of the freezer. Storing ice cream in the freezer door can lead to inconsistent temperatures due to the repeated opening and closing.

To maintain the quality and consistency of the ice cream, always ensure the lid of the ice cream container is tightly shut when stored in the freezer, reducing the chances of ice crystal formation.

Enjoy Your Homemade Ice Cream at Its Best with the Right Container

Searching for the best homemade ice cream container involves many considerations, from size and material durability to lid tightness. When you have the right container, you ensure the freshness and quality of your homemade treat, making the whole process a lot sweeter.

After researching different containers for homemade ice cream, I found that the SUMO 1.5-quart 2 Tubs containers worked best for keeping the treats fresh and delicious. Thanks to the airtight seal and sturdy construction, ice cream stays perfectly frozen.

So, don’t let anything stand between you and your deliciously creamy creations. Choose wisely and enjoy your homemade ice cream to its fullest.

Last update on 2024-12-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API